Sources

Where this site gets its facts

The site is built from Church documents, reporting and reference works reviewed in October 2026. Where accounts disagree, the notes below say which version the site follows.

Church and primary

News

Reference and history

Travel

Where sources differ

Accounts disagree on several points. Where they do, this site follows the bishop's declaration or the shrine's own current account.

Conflicting facts and the version used on this site
TopicWhat this site says
Alphonsine's ageMost accounts say 16; some say 17.
Where Alphonsine is todayThe shrine's 2026 account says she is a religious sister in Italy. Older sources place her with the Poor Clares in Abidjan.
How Marie Claire diedThe shrine says she was killed with her husband in 1994 while fleeing Kigali.
Where Nathalie is todayShe lives at Kibeho, beside the apparition site.
Date of the vision of blood15 August 1982, following the bishop and the shrine. Some sources say 19 August.
Who approved devotion in 1988The local bishop of the time. Some accounts credit Bishop Misago, but he did not become a bishop until 1992.
1994 death toll at the parish churchThousands. Estimates range from about 5,000 to more than 25,000.
1995 death toll at the campEstimates range from about 330 to more than 4,000.
Annual pilgrim numbersNo reliable yearly total exists. Feast days draw the largest crowds: more than 80,000 came on 15 August 2026.

Photography

The photographs of Kibeho come from Wikimedia Commons and are used under the Creative Commons licence named with each one. They have been resized for the web and are otherwise unaltered.

Books and film

  • Our Lady of Kibeho

    Immaculée Ilibagiza

    The story of the apparitions, told by a Rwandan survivor of the genocide and the author of Left to Tell.

  • If Only We Had Listened

    Sean Bloomfield

    A documentary film about the apparitions and the 1994 genocide.

Sources reviewed October 2026.

The short version

Start with the story